Putting research evidence into practice using the mystery face procedure [Ref 0.01]

Academic team: Dr Catriona Havard, Prof Graham Pike, Dr Hayley Ness, Dr Virginia Harrison
Policing partners: Greater Manchester Police
Status: Complete

A review of eyewitness identification research revealed that the results of research and the recommendations of researchers are not currently reflected in policing legislation or procedural guidelines. For example, the use of double-blind procedures by the world's police forces is very rare indeed, and not present in UK guidelines, despite its prominence in the recommendations of key learned societies (e.g. APA and BPS).

The project explored some of the reasons behind the disjuncture between research and practice by surveying UK police officer’s knowledge of, and attitudes, towards eyewitness research, and also their opinions of current practice in this area. The results showed that police officers, including those actively involved in eyewitness identification, have a very poor knowledge of relevant research and recommendations. The survey also showed that officers believe current procedures work well, although they also indicated that they wanted to learn more about current research of relevance to their profession.

Interestingly, officers’ estimates of rates of identification of an innocent suspect were comparable to those from research. Taken together with responses about the changes to identification procedures that officers would like to be implemented, these findings indicate that a key potential problem remains the difference between the underlying goals of researchers, who are concerned with preventing misidentifications, and the police, who are primarily concerned with increasing positive identifications.

Outputs

TitleOutputs typeLead academicYear
Executive summaryReportPike, G2017
Final reportReportPike, G2017
PresentationPresentationPike, G2017
Police perceptions of eyewitness evidence and researchConference paperHarrison, V2015
Are children less reliable at making visual identifications than adults? A reviewJournal articleHavard, C2014

News

CPRL’s new Executive Group will help shape the future of policing research

We're pleased to announce the formation of CPRL’s Executive Group and to welcome Tony Blaker, Bev Cripps, Phil Davies, Scott Hague, Melanie Jones, Carolyn Lovell, William Lyne and Trevor Pearce. They bring a wide range of police officer and police staff experience, from operational command and criminal investigation to workforce development, digital transformation and the use of science in policing. Their experience will help us deliver our new strategy and sharpen our judgement about where CPRL can make the greatest contribution.

19th November 2026